Monday, July 23, 2018

A new movie version of Fahrenheit 451: A frightening future world where firefighters set fires

A new movie version of Fahrenheit 451: A frightening future world where firefighters set fires By David Walsh 23 July 2018

Movie Trailer on Youtube (2:10 min) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mNKwe9k55fs



Directed by Ramin Bahrani; written by Bahrani and Amir Naderi; based on the novel by Ray Bradbury

Ramin Bahrani, the Iranian-American filmmaker, responsible for two of the more humane films made in the US in the past 15 years, Chop Shop (2007) and 99 Homes (2015), has directed a new version of Ray Bradbury’s novel, Fahrenheit 451, published in 1953. It aired on HBO and is available online.

French director François Truffaut’s well-known adaptation of the novel, featuring Oskar Werner and Julie Christie, was released in 1966.

The novel and the two film versions based on it have many differences, but they all include the central character of Guy Montag, the “fireman” who, in a future, authoritarian America, has the job of setting fires —specifically, of burning books (451°F is “the temperature at which book paper catches fire and burns,” according to the novel’s tagline).

Reading books has been made illegal on the grounds that it only generates discord and unhappiness, and an ultra-banal, conformist culture has been imposed on the population through the most up-to-date technology.

Ray Bradbury in 1975

When Bradbury began working on the novel, in the late 1940s, the first wave of Nazi book-burnings in May 1933 were still fresh in humanity’s collective memory, and only a few years had passed since the end of the Hitler regime itself. Moreover, the repression and conformism of the McCarthy era in America disturbed and angered Bradbury. In fact, as the author explained in a 1993 foreword, initial efforts to find a magazine publisher for portions of Fahrenheit 451 “came to a dead end. No one wanted to take a chance on a novel about past, present or future censorship.”

In Ramin Bahrani’s new adaptation, Montag (Michael B. Jordan) is a firefighter in Cleveland. The US, following a Second Civil War, is ruled by the Ministry, a dictatorial regime that spies on and closely controls its citizens, using repression, drugs and media over-stimulation in equal proportion.

Michael B. Jordan in Fahrenheit 451

News and information are restricted to the all-pervasive, government-run Internet, projected onto the sides of glittering high-rises and broadcast in homes, called “The 9.” Books are banned with a few exceptions and subject to burning by firefighters like Montag. All unauthorized writing is labeled “graffiti.” The Ministry, a merger of the state and the giant technology firms, rewrites or eradicates history.

Montag at first does his job enthusiastically and unthinkingly. His personal assistant device, Yuxie, doles out drugs and conversation. Montag works under the fierce Captain Beatty (Michael Shannon), who spends his nights writing tortured aphorisms (“To live is to suffer—but to suffer is to find meaning in one’s suffering”) on cigarette paper, only to later burn them.

An encounter with an informant, Clarisse (Sofia Boutella), who has connections with the “Eels” (book-reading outlaws) and who knows something of America’s actual history and how the Ministry came to power, proves fateful. She disabuses Montag, for example, of the notion, circulated by the current powers that be, that Benjamin Franklin established the first fire department in America for the purpose of burning books.

Through Clarisse, however, Beatty and the firefighters also learn of the existence of a house filled with books, an entire secret library. When the books’ owner prefers to martyr herself and die in the flames with her volumes, Montag’s complacent world is irreparably shaken. He steals a copy of Dostoyevsky’s Notes from Underground and soon becomes obsessed with reading.

Ultimately, Montag deserts Beatty and company and joins forces with Clarisse and a group of Eels who have a grandiose and unlikely plan for preserving the entirety of human culture.

Sofia Boutella in Fahrenheit 451

Bahrani and co-scenarist (veteran Iranian director and screenwriter) Amir Naderi have decided to represent a dark and gloomy potential future reality through creating a dark and gloomy film. Virtually every scene in this Fahrenheit 451 is set at night. Considerable effort has gone into creating a tension-filled, intimidating urban environment and atmosphere, presided over and manipulated by a fascistic techno-elite.

Some of this is effective, and telling, including the oft-repeated official slogans, “Stay Vivid” and “See Something, Say Something,” The firefighters’ drunken and backward delirium, their brutal chants as they prepare for a raid, hint at American military violence in Iraq and elsewhere. The hunting of immigrants is also suggested. Beatty’s cry, “Time to burn for America again,” presumably refers to a recent campaign slogan. That technology corporations, hand in hand with the government, might turn to censorship and repression is not the stuff of science fiction, but a present-day reality.

There are digs here then at the “war on terror,” at Donald Trump, at the anti-immigrant campaign, at National Security Agency spying, at identity politics, at corporate power.

But the digs largely remain digs. Why? In part, it would seem, because the ideas underlying this Fahrenheit 451 are diffuse and confused.

In an essay published in the New York Times May 10 (“Why ‘Fahrenheit 451’ Is the Book for Our Social Media Age”), Bahrani argued that the original novel was thoroughly “relevant” today. “For Bradbury, books were repositories of knowledge and ideas. He feared a future in which those things would be endangered, and now that future was here: The internet and new social-media platforms—and their potential threat to serious thought—would be at the heart of my adaptation.”

Bahrani observed that “Bradbury was no Luddite. … But in Fahrenheit 451 Bradbury was warning us about the threat of mass media to reading, about the bombardment of digital sensations that could substitute for critical thinking.”

The director asserted in the Times that “Bradbury feared memory loss. Today we have designated Google and our social-media accounts as the guardians of our memories, emotions, dreams and facts. As tech companies consolidate power, imagine how easy it could be to rewrite Benjamin Franklin’s Wiki entry to match what the firemen in Bradbury’s novel learn about the history of the fire department.”

Michael Shannon in Fahrenheit 451

The danger to serious and critical thought emerges not from the technologies, but from the irrational and outdated ownership or control of these technologies by private, capitalist interests and the reactionary, anti-social purposes to which they can be put. They also have a potentially liberating, democratic side to them.

And the threat to critical thinking certainly has not arrived—whether Bradbury held this view or not—because, as the film director suggested in the Times, “ we wanted the world to become this way … we asked for the firemen to burn books … we wanted entertainment to replace reading and thinking … we voted for political and economic systems to keep us happy rather than thoughtfully informed.” (Emphasis added).

These conceptions have helped lead the filmmakers along a false path. They cannot be substantiated or dramatized in an aesthetically satisfying manner. The often morose, sour, guilt-ridden looks of the characters do not accomplish what Bahrani wants them to. They don’t overcome the holes in the narrative.

A Second Civil War has occurred, we are told, in which 8 million people died. A “Civil War” between which forces? The Ministry claims sweepingly that ideas contained in books assisted in setting the stage for the bloody divisiveness. What ideas? What were the divisions? What were people fighting about?

The lack of concreteness about how the society ended up as it did, with the implication that somehow “we” were at fault, lends a pessimistic and misanthropic coloring to the film. A catastrophic event has taken place and it’s essentially taken for granted. There’s something both unserious and unlikely about this.

The quasi-morbid notions direct Bahrani, whether he likes it or not, back toward the conventions and tropes of contemporary studio filmmaking, which are sustained by approximately the same meager outlook. In terms of the film’s look, its overall tone, its action sequences, he finds what he needs, so to speak, in current cinema all too easily.

What should be a stinging and complex critique of a debased culture and repressive political system reduces itself largely to a succession of sullen faces, barking voices, harsh actions and murky images that would not be out of place in one of Hollywood’s darker “blockbusters” these days (Christopher Nolan, etc.). The filmmakers have taken the line of least resistance. It is disappointing.

Michael Shannon and Michael B. Jordan in Fahrenheit 451

Jordan (Fruitvale Station, Creed) has a few moments of inner conflict and irresolution, but Shannon, a truly fine actor under the right circumstances (including in Bahrani’s 99 Homes ), is unconvincingly and monotonously harsh and Boutella almost unrelievedly surly and even self-pitying. There is very little that is moving or affecting in their fates.

Sadly, even the impact of the shocking motif of the firefighter whose job in this authoritarian society is to start fires is dissipated in the grim, noisy swirl. Because everything is so ghastly, the viewer tends to be inured to the specific ghastliness of Montag’s activities. Its unnaturalness and horror doesn’t stand out as it should.

The opening of Bradbury’s novel remains chilling and disturbing:

“It was a pleasure to burn.

“It was a special pleasure to see things eaten, to see things blackened and changed. With the brass nozzle in his fists, with this great python spitting its venomous kerosene upon the world, the blood pounded in his head, and his hands were the hands of some amazing conductor playing all the symphonies of blazing and burning to bring down the tatters and charcoal ruins of history. With his symbolic helmet numbered 451 on his stolid head, and his eyes all orange flame with the thought of what came next, he flicked the igniter and the house jumped up in a gorging fire that burned the evening sky red and yellow and black. He strode in a swarm of fireflies. He wanted above all, like the old joke, to shove a marshmallow on a stick in the furnace, while the flapping pigeon-winged books died on the porch and lawn of the house. While the books went up in sparkling whirls and blew away on a wind turned dark with burning.

“Montag grinned the fierce grin of all men singed and driven back by flame.

“He knew that when he returned to the firehouse, he might wink at himself, a minstrel man, burnt-corked, in the mirror. Later, going to sleep, he would feel the fiery smile still gripped by his face muscles, in the dark. It never went away, that smile, it never ever went away, as long as he remembered.”

In François Truffaut’s Fahrenheit 451, the filmmaker organized the awfulness of the fireman’s occupation to contrast sharply with the relatively ordinary surroundings. The French filmmaker set out “to film fantastic things as if they were everyday, everyday things as if they were fantastic, and to mingle one with the other.”

Oskar Werner and Julie Christie in Fahrenheit 451

The following conversation in the Truffaut version between Montag (Werner) and Clarisse (Christie) about his book-burning duties is made more unsettling by the everyday suburban setting (albeit with a few “futuristic” touches):

Clarisse: Why do you burn books ?

Montag: What? Well, it’s a job like any other. Good work with lots of variety. Monday, we burn Miller; Tuesday, Tolstoy; Wednesday, Walt Whitman; Friday, Faulkner; and Saturday and Sunday, Schopenhauer and Sartre. “We burn them to ashes and then burn the ashes.” That’s our official motto.

Clarisse: You don’t like books then?

Montag: Do you like the rain?

Clarisse: Yes, I adore it.

Montag: Books are just so much … rubbish. They have no interest.

Clarisse: Then why do some people still read them although it’s so dangerous?

Montag: Precisely because it is forbidden.

Clarisse: Why is it forbidden?

Montag: Because it makes people unhappy.

Clarisse: Do you really believe that?

Montag: Oh, yes. Books disturb people. They make them antisocial.

Truffaut’s film is not entirely successful, but it does contain a number of affecting sequences, including the sharp crisis into which Montag’s sudden doubts and new habit of reading throw his drug-addled, television-addicted wife (also played by Christie). The final, snowy scene of the self-exiled “book people” (individuals who have taken it upon themselves to memorize and “become” a particular work), living out of doors in the countryside, is tremendously evocative and poignant. One feels here Truffaut’s genuine love of culture and literature.

The decline in historical “memory” is a harmful fact of contemporary life, and not only in the US, which has to be fought and overcome. How much, one wonders, does Bahrani know, for example, about the influence of the 1917 October Revolution on Iran, about the impact of Stalinism, about the role of the Tudeh Party in Iran and the various Communist Parties in the Middle East and many other historical issues?

If the Bahrani-Naderi version of Fahrenheit 451 had focused more soberly and objectively on what “book-burning” and “memory loss” mean today in our concrete social circumstances, it might have been a meaningful contribution. As it is, unfortunately, their work will make little more impact than any of the other garden variety, self-consciously ominous “dystopian” films around, which are more or less a dime a dozen at present.

David Harvey’s Jacobin interview on Marx’s Capital A promotion of the “life-style” politics

David Harvey’s Jacobin interview on Marx’s Capital A promotion of the “life-style” politics of the pseudo-left By Nick Beams 21 July 2018



(Vimeo - video of David Harvey's Introduction to Reading Karl Marx' 'Capital' - https://vimeo.com/13535463 )



The Jacobin magazine, which functions as a kind of house journal for the middle class pseudo-left milieu, in particular the Democratic Socialists of America, has published an interview with the academic David Harvey, purporting to show why Marx’s Capital is “still the defining guide to understanding—and overcoming—the horrors of capitalism.”

Harvey, variously described as a social theorist, a historical-materialist geographer and sometimes a Marxist, has attracted a wide following over the past decade in the wake of the global financial crisis due to his online lectures on Capital and a number of books critical of capitalism and its irrationalities.

The interest in his writings and lectures, particularly from among younger people and students, is an expression of the growing hostility to capitalism, increasingly regarded as having failed, and the growing receptiveness towards socialism, coupled with a turn to Marx in the search for answers to the mounting problems and crises caused by the ongoing breakdown of the capitalist order.

But as with all of Harvey’s work, this interview does not provide a clarification or guide to Marx but serves to prevent an understanding of his masterwork, seeking to render him suitable to the political and life-style sensibilities of a middle class “left” audience.

This emerges from the very outset of the interview. Asked to give an overview of the three volumes of Capital, Harvey says: “Marx is very much into detail and it’s sometimes hard to get a sense of exactly what the whole concept of Capital is about.” This has been a recurring theme virtually since the day Capital was published—that it is too difficult and too dense to be comprehended.

Capital is certainly no easy work but that difficulty arises not from Marx but from the fact that capitalism is the most complex form of socio-economic organisation in the historical development of mankind.

However, as Harvey well knows, Marx provided a very clear explanation of the essential thread of his theoretical labours.

In the postface to the second edition of Capital, Marx favourably cited a Russian reviewer of the first edition published in 1867 who had set out the objective logic of his analysis.

The reviewer had begun by citing Marx’s famous Preface to the Critique of Political Economy, published in 1859, in which he set out the materialist basis of his method.

There Marx had written: “In the social production of their existence, men inevitably enter into definite relations, which are independent of their will, namely relations of production appropriate to a given stage in the development of their material forces of production. … At a certain stage of development, the material productive forces of society come into conflict with the existing social relations of production … From forms of development of the productive forces these relations turn into their fetters. Then begins an era of social revolution.”

Basing himself on this explanation, the Russian reviewer concluded that Marx “concerns himself with one thing: to show, by an exact scientific investigation, the necessity of successive determinate orders of social relations, and to establish, as impeccably as possible, the facts from which he starts out and on which he depends. For this it is quite enough if he proves, at the same time, both the necessity of the present order of things, and the necessity of another order into which the first must inevitably pass over.”

In other words, Capital was the application of the theory of historical materialism, worked out by Marx and Engels in the late 1840s, to the analysis of capitalist society in which the central social relation of production was the buying and selling of the labour power of the new social force, the working class, which this society had brought into being. It was aimed at demonstrating how the very development of the productive forces to which this new social order had given rise inevitably came into conflict with the social relations on which it was based, leading to social revolution and the transition to a new and higher form of society.

While Capital was grounded on a thorough-going scientific analysis of capitalist society, it was not an academic treatise. It was written with the aim of providing the working class, its historical gravedigger, with the theoretical weapons necessary for its overthrow and the transition to a higher socio-economic order, international socialism.

It is highly significant, therefore, that in Harvey’s interview on Capital and its significance, the words “social revolution” and “working class” never appear.

What then is the essential content of the interview? It is the dressing up in Marxist-sounding terminology of the politics of the middle class pseudo-left, focusing on protests against some of the irrationalities and outrages of the capitalist system, concerned not with its overthrow but “life-style changes.” Its role is to seek to divert those seeking answers away from a real grappling with and understanding of Marx’s masterwork.

Harvey presents the three volumes of Capital as something of a jumble, that Marx was saying “in volume one, I deal with this, in volume two I deal with that and in volume three I deal with something else.”

Harvey goes on to say that Marx has in mind “the totality of the circulation of capital” but then points to a problem because Marx did not complete volumes two and three (they were edited by Engels from Marx’s drafts) and so they “aren’t as satisfactory as volume one.”

The upshot of this focus on circulation is twofold. First, it leaves the impression that there is no inherent logic to Marx’s presentation. Second, it downplays the centrality of capitalist production, dissolving it in the process of circulation, a move which, as we shall see, forms a key foundation of Harvey’s political perspective.

Contrary to Harvey, Marx is very clear on the logic of the three volumes, which he sets out at the beginning of volume three.

There he explains that the investigation in volume one concerns the process of capitalist production itself, leaving out the external secondary influences on this process. But as he notes, the analysis does not complete the life cycle of capital and so in volume two he considers how the process of production is supplemented by the process of circulation.

In volume three the issue is to “discover and present the concrete forms which grow out of the process of capital’s movement considered as a whole.”

“The configurations of capital, as developed in this volume,” he writes, “thus approach step by step the form in which they appear on the surface of society, in the action of different capitals on one another, i.e., in competition, and in the everyday consciousness of the agents of production themselves.” [1]

The materialist method employed by Marx is to ascend from the most abstract forms to the concrete. Capital, therefore, begins with the cell-form of the capitalist economy, the commodity, in which the product of human labour—the basis of all society—presents itself in the social form of a product produced for exchange.

The significance of this starting point was noted by Lenin:

“In his Capital, Marx first analyses the simplest, most ordinary and fundamental, most common and everyday relation of bourgeois (commodity) society, a relation encountered billions of times, viz. the exchange of commodities. In this very simple phenomenon (in this ‘cell’ of bourgeois society) analysis reveals all the contradictions (or the germs of all the contradictions) of modern society. The subsequent exposition shows us the development (both growth and movement) of these contradictions and of this society in the summation of its individual parts, from its beginning to its end.” [2]

From the analysis of the commodity and its value, Marx reveals the origin of money as the material expression of value. The analysis of money discloses the nature of capital as self-expanding value.

The most decisive breakthrough made by Marx was to discover the source of this self-expansion. The issue which had tortured the minds of Marx’s classical predecessors in the science of political economy, in particular its two leading representatives, Adam Smith and David Ricardo, was how, on the basis of market relations in which equivalents exchange for equivalents, could a surplus arise? In particular, how out of the most important exchange in commodity-capitalist society, could profit rise, if equivalents were exchanged for equivalents according to the laws of the market.

Marx established that the commodity that the worker sold to the capitalist was not his or her labour, as had previously been maintained, but the capacity to work, or labour power.

Like every other commodity its value was determined by the time taken to reproduce it, that is, it was determined by the value of the commodities needed to sustain the worker and enable the raising of a family to produce the next generation of wage workers.

The surplus value appropriated by the capitalist owner of the means of production, to whom the worker sold his or her labour power, arose from the fact that the value of labour power was less than the value created by the worker in the course of the working day. That is, while it may take, say three hours, for the worker to reproduce the value of labour power, the working day extended for much longer and this additional, or surplus, value fell to capital.

This epoch-making discovery had vast political implications. Marx was by no means the first socialist. Others before him had trenchantly criticised the operations of the capitalist system and pointed to its irrationalities, the increasing exploitation of the working class and widening social inequality. But as Engels explained:

“The socialism of earlier days certainly criticised the existing capitalistic mode of production and its consequences. It could not explain them, and, therefore could not get the mastery of them. It could only simply reject them as bad.” [3]

It was necessary, Engels continued, to present the capitalist mode of production as necessary during a given historical period and also to present the inevitability of its downfall and to lay bare its essential character. The critics had attacked its evil consequences rather than reveal the secret of the thing itself. This was revealed by the discovery of surplus value.

With these two great discoveries, he concluded, the materialist conception of history and the revelation of the secret of capitalist production, socialism became a science. The next step was to work out the details.

Marx’s discoveries revealed that not only was the working class an exploited class but, in laying bare the source of that exploitation in the social relations of capitalism itself, established that it was a revolutionary class. That is, to secure its own emancipation the working class had to overthrow the entire system of social relations, deriving from wage-labour—on which capitalism was grounded.

One of the most important “details” to which Engels referred, was the way in which the contradiction between the growth of the productive forces under capitalism and the social relations based on wage-labour—the contradiction that was the driving force of social revolution—manifested itself in the capitalist economy.

This was discovered by Marx in his analysis of the tendency of the rate of profit to fall. He demonstrated that this tendency—the nemesis of the capitalist mode of production whose driving force is profit—arose from the very development of the productive forces to which it gave rise.

The sole source of surplus value and profit, the basis for the self-expansion of capital, is the living labour of the working class. But the more capital grows the greater must be the extraction of surplus value from the working class in order to expand it yet again. To the extent that the extraction of surplus value fails to keep pace with the growth of capital, the rate of profit tends to fall. This leads to a crisis to which capital responds by reorganising production, in order to intensify exploitation in order to continue. But the very development of these crises, growing ever more serious, drives the working class into struggle against the capitalist system and its ruling class.

This is the source of the realities of “everyday life,” as Marx put it, in which we see the vast accumulation of wealth and an enormous growth in the productive forces and the social productivity of labour on the one hand and the growth of poverty, misery and degradation, accompanied by ever widening social inequality on the other.

The discovery of the secret of surplus value as the basis of the capitalist accumulation process and the contradictions arising from it, had, as we noted, far-reaching political implications. It concretised, as Marx had set out in in his early writings, the revolutionary role of the working class.

“It is not a question of what this or that proletarian, or even the whole proletariat, at the moment regards as its aim. It is a question of what the proletariat is, and what, in accordance with this being, it will historically be compelled to do. Its aim and historical action is visibly and irrevocably foreshadowed in its own life situation, as well as in the whole organisation of bourgeois society.”[4]

The key to Harvey’s politics is his rejection of and outright hostility to the analysis made by Marx of the revolutionary role of the working class which is central to Capital. Therefore, as far as his “socialism” is concerned it is clouded in the mists of pre-Marxist conceptions.

“Capital has built the capacity, technologically and organisationally, to create a far better world,” he says in the Jacobin interview. “But it does so through social relations of domination rather than emancipation. This is the central contradiction. And Marx keeps saying, ‘Why don’t we use all of this technological and organisational capacity to create a world which is liberatory, rather than one which is about domination?”

Here Harvey follows the road taken by previous “social theorists” who, while identifying some of the irrationalities of the capitalist mode of production, separated Marx’s scientific analysis of capitalism from its central purpose, that is, the arming of the working class for the revolutionary struggles in which it is driven by the crises of the profit system.

The Frankfurt School, for example, sought the agency for social transformation—insofar as it had not completely abandoned such a perspective—in the “cultural criticism” of the irrationalities of capitalism and “consumerism.”

Paul Sweezy, the “independent Marxist”, writing in the 1960s, wrote off the working class in the advanced capitalist countries and glorified the national liberation movements in what was then known as the Third World.

Herbert Marcuse, the darling of the New Left in the 1960s, maintained that the working class had been completely integrated into advanced capitalist society—and was even a potential basis for fascism—and found the agency for social change in the marginalised sections of society.

On the basis of his historical materialist analysis, Marx was well aware of the fact that the advancement in the productive force under capitalism had created the basis for socialist society, free of class exploitation and domination “in which the free development of each is the condition for the free development of all.”

But he rejected as utopian any perspective which sought to bring about this transformation by drawing out the contrast between what was possible under a different form of social organisation and what presently existed in capitalist society. Such a perspective made the socialist transformation a question of the criticism of capitalist society by so-called enlightened individuals.

The crucial question for Marx was what was the social material force—the class—created by capitalist society itself, which would be the agency, the driving force, of this transformation. Today, the point at issue is not that socialism will somehow be more advantageous for humanity—that was already clear in Marx’s day—but that it is an historic necessity if human civilisation is to survive and progress.

The contradictions of capitalism are not, as Harvey attempts to portray them, the contrast between what would be possible under socialism as compared to present reality but are rooted in the inexorable drive of the profit system towards the impoverishment of the working class, the development of authoritarian forms of rule and war, threatening the very destruction of human civilisation, and a relapse into barbarism. For socialism to become a reality and not simply a dream of human advancement, there must be a social force in capitalist society whose material interests drive it forward to its realisation. That force is the working class, that is, the class separated from the control and ownership of the productive forces which is compelled in order to sustain its existence to sell its labour power.

One of the most significant historical developments of the past three decades has been the transformation of the overwhelming majority of the world’s population into proletarians, forced to sell their labour power. Hundreds of millions of peasants in China, India and elsewhere have been transformed into wage workers while in the advanced capitalist countries hundreds of millions of people, employed in what were once considered secure “middle class” occupations, have discovered, through relentless job cuts, downsizing and cuts in their incomes, that they are proletarians with nothing to sell but their labour power, no less than the millions engaged in the factories.

In his criticism of the utopian socialists of his day, Marx pointed to their dreams of experimental realisation of their social utopia as they opposed all political action by the working class.

It is therefore significant that Harvey says nothing in his interview about the resurgent movement of the working class, manifested in the widespread teachers’ strikes in the US, the strike movements in Europe and in countries such as India after decades of suppression by the trade unions and the social democratic and labour parties, and focuses attention on “life-style” movements.

“Now, there are revolts against certain things that are happening,” he writes. “People are beginning to say, ‘look, we want something different.’ I find little communities all around the place in urban areas, and in rural areas, too, where people are trying to set up a different lifestyle. The ones that interest me most are those which use new technologies, like cell phones and the internet, to create an alternative lifestyle with different forms of social relations than those characteristic of corporations, with hierarchical structures of power, that we encounter in our daily lives. To struggle over a lifestyle is rather different than struggling over wages or conditions of labour in a factory.”

Of course Harvey does not leave matters there. He would rapidly lose all credibility in the eyes of those who consider him to be an interpreter and a guide to Marx if he did. And so he maintains that those who are struggling over lifestyle issues, or race, or the environment need to recognise from the standpoint of the totality of capital the relationship between those struggles and how they are related to the forms of production. Putting them all together provides a picture of what a capitalist society is all about “and the kinds of dissatisfactions and alienations that exist in different components of the circulation of capital, which Marx identifies.”

Harvey recognises the struggle of the working class, though it is not so much as mentioned in the interview, but he identifies it as purely the struggle over wages and conditions within a given factory, and thus purely within a trade union perspective.

But as workers are coming to realise, on the basis of their experiences, even struggles which begin on this limited basis rapidly extend to embody broader, political, issues. Workers fighting for improved wages and conditions are immediately confronted not just with the management of the individual corporation or firm within which they work but the apparatuses of the trade union bureaucracy and behind them the capitalist government and the state.

Every struggle of the working class, whether it begins over wages, social conditions, health, pensions or today the increasing use of internet censorship to try to prevent them organising themselves, places them more and more directly in conflict with the entire capitalist organisation of society and raises the question of political power, that is, which class is to rule. As Marx put it, every class struggle is, therefore, a political struggle.

The political aim of Harvey’s work now comes into clearer focus. It is aimed at subordinating the struggles of the working class to the politics of the pseudo-left and middle classes concerned with questions of sexual orientation, life style and individual, not class, identity.

This political orientation makes clear why Harvey, insofar as he deals with questions of political economy and the structure of Capital, seeks to downplay the centrality of production and dissolve it into the question of the circulation of capital.

He maintains that if one really wants to understand Marx’s conception of capital, “then you can’t just understand it as just being about production. It’s about circulation. It’s about getting it to the market and selling it, then it’s about distributing the profits.”

The issues related to circulation and the distribution of profits are, of course, vital to an understanding of the capitalist economy, its movement and contradictions. But the key point at issue is this: what is the essential determinant of the structure of society, its political relations and state apparatus and the driving force of its development.

In volume three of Capital, Marx directly addresses this question as follows:

“The specific economic form in which the unpaid surplus labour is pumped out of the direct producers determines the relationship of domination and servitude, as this grows directly out of production itself and reacts back on it as a determinant. On this is based the entire configuration of the economic community arising from the actual relations of production and hence also its specific political form.”

It is in the direct relationship of the owners of the conditions of production to the immediate producers, Marx continues, “in which we find the innermost secret, the hidden basis of the entire social edifice, and with it the political form of the relation of sovereignty and dependence, in short, the corresponding specific form of the state.”[5]

As Marx goes on to point out, the same economic forms can display variations and gradations in the political forms of rule, depending on a series of external factors and historical circumstances. But there is no question that the essential content of these various political forms is the mode in which surplus labour is pumped out of the immediate producers.

Volume one of Capital is concerned with the way in which under capitalism, a specific historical mode of production, this unpaid surplus labour is pumped out of the immediate producers, the working class, through the system of social relations based on wage labour to yield surplus value.

Harvey wants to de-emphasise or outright dissolve this fundamental structural foundation by pointing out that there is more to capitalism than simply the production of surplus value—there is also the process of realisation, detailed in volume two and distribution in volume three.

However, the essential foundation of capitalism is in production—not the production of commodities as such, or the means of production, the production of the material needs of society as a living organism—but the production of surplus value which forms the essential driving force of this society.

Volume two is concerned with the relationships pertaining to realisation. But this, it must be emphasised, is the realisation of the surplus value, its transformation from the commodity form back into money so the process of surplus value extraction can begin again. Likewise, volume three is concerned with the distribution of this surplus value among the various owners of property in the form of profit, interest and rent.

In his recent writings, Harvey has drawn out the connection between his focus on the process of circulation and realisation and his downplaying of the centrality of the production of surplus value and his political perspective.

In his latest book, Marx, Capital and the Madness of Economic Reason, Harvey writes:

“Struggles at the point of valorisation inevitably have a class character … Those at the point of realisation focus on buyers and sellers and trigger fights against the predatory practices and accumulation by dispossession in the market place … Such struggles are not well theorised. In the field of social reproduction issues of social hierarchy, gender, sexuality, kinship and family and the like become much more predominant and the primary political focus shifts to the qualities of daily life rather than the labour process. These struggles have often been ignored in the Marxist literature.”

What follows from this dissolving of the centrality of the production of surplus value within the capitalist system is that “the social and political struggles against the power of capital within the totality of capital circulation take different forms and call for different kinds of strategic alliances if they are to succeed.”[6]

There is no question what kind of “strategic alliances” Harvey has in mind—alliances with sections of the radical petty bourgeoisie and its concern for life-style politics and even sections of the bourgeoisie itself.

This is done on the basis of a misrepresentation of Capital, implying that it was not directed to politically and theoretically arming the working class for social revolution but was aimed at merely drawing out the irrationalities of capitalist society.

By this means, Harvey is seeking to misdirect those who are turning to Marx and have followed his own work in the hope that it might provide a guide. He seeks to divert them away from a struggle in the working class, to mobilise it as an independent revolutionary force, and channel them into the milieu of pseudo-left and middle-class radical politics and there to fight for “strategic alliances” that ensure the continued domination of the bourgeoisie and capital.

Notes:

[1] Marx, Capital Volume 3 (London: Penguin, 1991) p. 117 [2] Lenin, Collected Works Volume 38 (London: Lawrence and Wishart, 1961) p. 360 [3] Engels, Anti-Dühring (Moscow: Progress Publishers, 1969) p. 38 [4] Marx, The Holy Family (Moscow: Progress Publishers, 1975) pp. 44–45 [5] Marx, Capital Volume 3 (London: Penguin 1993) p. 927 [6] David Harvey, Marx, Capital and the Madness of Economic Reason (New York: Oxford University Press, 2018) p. 48

Sunday, July 22, 2018

Dating Site - Adult Friend Finder - Review – PROS & CONS

Adult Friend Finder Review – PROS & CONS March 18, 2018

Adult Friend Finder is definitely your one-stop shop which provides all there is to be provided by any hookup site. It brings to your door step a wide range of choices and preferences. You can venture deeper and seek choices based on your own preferences or you can even interact with users having a wide range of other preferences which may have been less familiar to you.

This site has a higher degree of profiles which contain a larger range of explicit content or pictures. This site simply screams of casual and easy to get hook ups. It functions under the flagship of Adult Friend Finders Network and has been boon for all the people who are interested in having casual hookups online or even in person.

PROS

Adult Friend Finder is an established legit website since 1996 & packing millions of users worldwide. The feature called What’s Hot lets you interact with the hottest profile user who is trending currently on the site. This lets you be on top of things and trends. There are a wide range of search options which could cater to almost any kind of whims and fancies of any man. There is a plethora of options for discovery, communication and online bling.

CONS

There is a lack of data driven matching system. The site does not have any robust algorithm. As a hook up app, Adult Friend Finder does not offer any elaborate questionnaire which will help you match your profile with other users. No algorithm can function or even suggest partners. It becomes very difficult to find a compatible partner.

This dating site can be said to be the unfiltered oasis of sexual encounters and singles. Actually you may not even be a single person. What is important is that you just be interested in intimate sexual counters.

6 REASONS TO USE ADULT FRIEND FINDER:

1. Adult Friend Finder is Special!

Adult Friend Finder has all the basic features of a typical online dating site but what really sets it apart is the fact that it also provides a ton of extra tools as well. There are certain features which make the entire experience more interactive and stimulating. The site incorporates a good amount of detail regarding the information of various social media communities or even p**n sites. This information is available on personal blogs.

This interface acts as a platform through which you can easily live stream from sites. Other resources are also a click away from such sites. They provide some important dating advices (mostly senual advices). They also offer an option to join an academy which gives a course on fling advice.

2. PASSIVE OR ACTIVE USERS:

Members on this dating platform can either be passive or active users. You can choose to only browse and not make contact with any of the other user or you could also create a personal favorite hotlist of some of your favorite members. You can be a more active user by engaging in virtual love. In order to do this you could use an exclusive feature called the Connexion feature.

This enables you to indulge in digital as well as physical connection. You can send in some sensations via some of the paired s** toys. I mean this site has taken the realm of artificial intelligence to another level.

However it also depends on how much money you spend. This is directly proportional to which level of active or passive user you may be. It will be fairly difficult for a new user to initiate any sort of a conversation. However if you do want to be a free user my take is that you very prudently, with a play of words, fill up your profile. Think about what photos would lead you to a jackpot quiet literally and give your profile a bit of a boost and all you have to do is wait patiently till others contact you.

3. They Vouch For Customer's Satisfaction

The Adult FriendFinder vouches to satisfy all your whims and fancies that you have ever had regarding sensual encounters. It also a point system, a bling and tips system and lets you have virtual sensual encounters using your favorite sex toys with a model. This just keeps getting exciting by each passing day.

4. The Point System

The dating site operates on a point system which further helps to gamify the entire dating system and makes the entire process more pleasurable and fun to indulge yourself into. This also gives a boost to all kind of sexual imagination you can ever have. But everything has a price and so the imagination can run as wild as you want it to run and how much money are you willing to pay also.

So, how exactly do you earn these points?

You can either earn these points by indulging in some kind of an activity on site or you could simply buy these points using your credit card.

5. TIPS & BLING

In every typical you would use these points to buy some ammunition or some other extra amenities. So in this site, you use these points to ‘tip’ some member updates or to view some member images or even some other member video which you might like.

Now Bling is such a catchy word!

You can use these points to buy Bling. These Bling are basically badges. Using these batches you could view any number of naughty videos. This is also your gateway to get or purchase free membership prizes or even gets access to membership months. This will allow you to get an access to certain sites of the dating site.

6. Premium Membership is GOLD

The thing about premium membership is that it opens up windows to pretty much all sorts of social interactive interfaces for any user who plans on spending more or less than $20 dollars a month. This amount can further be reduced if the user plans on getting a different for a longer duration of time.

In order to use all the bling features and extra attractions added by the owners you must and it is advisable that you become a paid subscriber to Adult Friend Finder. Being a paid member you will be able to contact any user, no restriction there. Although you will be charged more barring the subscription fee if you wish to watch of the video sections.

You will get as much as you want to pour in. I mean you will have to let loose your coffers. This site will treat you well only if you can pay up. They are directly related. 2 REASONS TO NOT USE ADULT FRIEND FINDER

1. Pay More For More

You could be duped or rather, you may be paying for a premium subscriptions but even that subscription may not be able to cover some of the additional yet extremely features which are provided by this site. This includes model videos or even purchased points or the exclusive sex academy videos.

2. Lack of Research

Enough research has not been done. Maybe since they hardly collect any sort of data. Considering this shortcoming, the users barely have any idea of the male to female ratio of users. This may not come off as a major setback however, there is no database if things go wrong or there is no tab of any sort of information which might direct towards inefficiency.

How to Get Started With Adult Friend Finder? adult friend finder

There is a simple set up that you need to follow in order to sign up for adult Friend Finder. There are 5 steps that you must follow. They are as follows:

First off all you will need to fill in is your sexual orientation and what all interests or preferences you would like to pursue while using this best dating app.

Next, you must fill a blurb which consists of about 18 characters. This blurb will be like a bio.

Go ahead and make the necessary changes in the option which is called Cupid preferences. This will narrow down your search options and will present you with very specific options based on your choices, fetish, location, appearance, etc.

In your homepage there will be tons of provocative banners and ads and you can browse through the navigation bar which will be present at the top of the screen. Now, there will be an option called ‘What’s New’.

This option will keep you updated in every way and will showcase which all profiles are new ones or what all additions have been made. All these will feature based solely on the preferences that you have enlisted.

There is also an option called Live Action. The name itself indicates that this option will be the live chat room which you enjoy using.

WHY YOU SHOULD NOT BOTHER GETTING A SUBSCRIPTION: adult friendfinder review

This site involves a little bit of work from the side of the users. But looking at such a huge number of users and rapid activity going on, you will never find it a problem to get a suitable partner. However the kind of money that you constantly have to pour in may just not be everyone’s cup of tea.

In order to fully use you will be required to pay a premium subscription. If you are a free user, you are more or less a passive user. You cannot make much contact. Even if you pay for a premium membership it might not be enough after all. To view some of the other videos you will have to loosen your pockets a little bit more and pay a little more.

Also the site barely collects any kind of data from the users and that is a disadvantage considering there is no proper algorithm that would match us up with the appropriate kind of users. You are literally looking for a needle in hay.

This might not have a very strong algorithm system in place to hook you up with some other partner but the meat of the matter is it has morphed the adult dating site into a gaming site making the entire process of finding a suitable partner more exciting. You have a point system, you can have virtual sex, and you get relationship advice as well. These advice will however be more sexual in nature. That gives without saying.

This site works best for people who are willing to spend more. Even if you get a premium subscription, in order to view some of the other videos or profiles or pictures you will have to pay up a little more. You can choose for yourself how active or passive kind of a user you want to be.

The explicit sexual content that this site presents any user is unprecedented and even if it does have flaws pertaining to the match making, it covers that up in the sheer options that it provides.

https://www.besthookupapps.net/adult-friend-finder-review/

Who’s on the left and why it’s important to know - by Joe Sims - 20 July 2018



Who’s on the left and why it’s important to know July 20, 2018 By Joe Sims

I was struck by a headline I stumbled across on Facebook the other day that claimed “Bernie Sanders is not the left,” based on the apparent hesitation of Sanders to take a position supporting abolishing ICE, favored not only by DSAer Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, the winner of the historic Democratic primary in the Bronx and Queens last month, but also by the centrist presidential hopeful Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand, D-N.Y.

Apparently, Sanders’s cautiousness with regard to what his critics deem a clear-cut democratic and human rights issue is enough to cast him outside the pale. But is that fair? It’s an important question, complicated by the manner in which right, left, and center is determined in U.S. politics.

Historically, the terms left and right emerged out of the French Revolution’s National Assembly: those sitting on the right supported the King; those on the left, the revolution. Fair enough—reaction to the right, democracy and revolution to the left. But in our country, this clear divide is obscured by the portrayal of these terms as cultural issues. Stances taken on questions like gun control, reproductive rights, drug legalization, health care, the role of government, immigration, and standing for the national anthem, to mention only a few, are posed as the battle lines around which the country’s culture wars are waged between the conservative right and the “liberal” left.

But each of these issues goes beyond cultural matters. They are also political, social, and economic. Behind them lie interests and motives that, in large measure, determine where folks line up in the battles taking place across the breadth and width of the land.

Health care is a good example. The big hospital and pharmaceutical corporations are on the right side of this question: They oppose even partial measures like Obamacare’s provision on pre-existing conditions because it affects their profit margins. Unions and civil rights groups, on the other hand, lie squarely on the left: Workers benefit because the corporations are compelled to shoulder a larger part of the cost for healthcare, leaving more money in the pockets of those that need it most.

The same can be said for most every issue on which left and right line up.

Thus, another and more accurate way of assessing left or right is to judge how an issue in question affects class interests. Issues that benefit big business generally end up on the right wing side of things; those that benefit the working class are on the left.

Government regulation is another good example. Corporations favor less regulation because they don’t want rules governing the environment or worker health and safety to get in the way of profits. That’s why Wall Street and the Chamber of Commerce—mainly, but not exclusively—support the Republican Party: It’s in their class interest to do so.

But what about issues like abolishing ICE? Here too class interests are involved. A working-class and therefore left position would favor abolishing ICE as part of a program of comprehensive immigration reform and a path to citizenship. Why? Not only because it’s morally right, but also because so long as immigrant workers are not citizens, they can be more easily exploited by paying them less and denying them benefits.

So why the cautiousness on the part of Sanders when it comes to getting rid of ICE, which is essentially a deportation agency? It’s not so clear cut. It could be that a determination was made that opposing ICE would help the GOP among some working and middle class white voters caught up in Trump’s anti-immigrant hysteria. The thinking here is that the stakes in the midterm elections are so high that alienating even a fraction of potential Democratic voters is an error: A winning coalition must be achieved at all costs.

It’s an arguably reasonable position. But what it fails to understand is that the victims of racism are part of this winning coalition. Given the horrors on the U.S.-Mexican border and ICE’s role in separating families, will voters so affected come to polls if their electoral advocates fail to address these issues?

Fighting racism is key to achieving the electoral class unity needed to defeat the extreme right, particularly now. Normalizing racist police tactics, whether on the border or in urban communities, only contributes to the growing fascist danger. A working-class left approach would see that ICE is tearing families apart and that racism is dividing the class. The left must help those workers confused by Trump to see how their interests also line up with abolishing ICE. If not us, who?

A section of the left that narrowly understands class has not understood the need to address such fundamental issues. The issue then is to understand the reasons that lay behind the kind of cautiousness supposedly expressed by Sanders. Taken by itself, caution is neither right nor left. In fact, caution could very well be a sign of maturity and revolutionary wisdom. However, if it’s connected to a non-struggle approach to workers influenced by Trump, it moves away from consistent left positions. Truth be told, this approach affected the outcome of the 2016 campaign.

That said, what of the notion that Sanders is not “the left?” Here, the Communist Party has argued that a broad left exists in the U.S. that is anti-corporate, pro-union, anti-sexist, pro-environment, pro-health care, anti-racist, and pro-LGBTQ rights. Sanders, who describes himself as a democratic socialist, is clearly in this camp. On the other hand, coming out of the non-Marxist social democratic left, he’s taken some positions which are not consistently pro-working class. That does not, however, cast him or those like him outside of left circles. The middle-class liberal left, when put under pressure, has a tendency to move to the right.

In such cases, it’s vitally important to avoid a sectarianism that pushes away erstwhile allies, recognizing that in political life, there’s the appearance of left-ness on the one hand (always being bold, militant, and uncompromising), and real left-ness on the other (judging every set of circumstances individually, assessing when to be bold or cautious, and deciding whether to be uncompromising or flexible).

Hence, a working-class approach suggests the need to work together on issues where there’s agreement and continuing to discuss and debate where there’s not.

In such a manner, “the left,” which we would define as organizations and individuals who are consistently pro-working class, can only grow in strength and influence.

This pro-working class left today is being formed in unique circumstances. It is taking shape in conditions of wage stagnation, enormous student debt, extreme inequality, economic instability, and potentially existential environmental threats. It is a left coming of age in the fight against racism, anti-immigrant nationalism, gross sexism, and a massive attack on democratic institutions.

It is a left that sees socialism as deeply democratic and egalitarian; sees health care, education, housing, and jobs as basic rights; and believes in the need for people’s control from below over every aspect of their own lives.

It is a left that must see the fight against racism as central to defeating the right.

It is a social media and social network-organized left being forged in the culture wars and the battle for truth. And at bottom, behind these cultural wars are class wars and class interests. If you’re uncertain where you stand, just ask, who benefits? If it’s the ruling class, you end up on the right; if it’s the working class, congratulations, you’re on the left!

https://archive.is/oeZsF

San Diego Comic Convention: The push for transgender representation in media continues



By Chauncey K. Robinson 20 July 2018

SAN DIEGO—One of the biggest conventions focusing on entertainment,

art, and popular culture kicked off here on July 19. The largest convention of its kind in the world, Comic Con International: San Diego (SDCC) is where close to 300,000 attendees descend annually in order to partake in panels and experiences that highlight and discuss culture, entertainment, and art. It’s also a time to discuss the current state of entertainment, its influence on society, and vice versa.

The SDCC panel “Transformation Magic: Transgender Life in Comics from Street Level to Stratosphere” highlighted the work transgender artists are contributing to culture, the need for representation, the struggles they face, and the hope for the future when it comes to representing the lives of transgender people. Although the recent emergence of the hit cable series Pose on FX has highlighted transgender actors and stories, the panel pushed for the continued need of transgender voices in media.

Although there have been many strides toward progress in combating discrimination against members of the LGBTQ community, studies have shown that transgender people still face pervasive forms of oppression and discrimination. The National Center for Transgender Equality and the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force conducted a study that found rampant discrimination against transgender people concerning the basic human right of health care. The Trump administration has tried to pass a number of discriminatory legislative measures that attack the rights and livelihoods of transgender people, along with other assaults on working people’s rights which many in the transgender community are part of. In the midst of this ongoing offensive, activists and artists have emerged in order to give a voice to the transgender community and the lives they lead. The panel on Thursday highlighted such efforts.

Moderated by cartoonist, editor, and publisher Tara Madison Avery, the panel included artists and writers Dylan Edwards (Qat Person), Erin Nations (Gumballs), Knave Murdok (TransCat), Gillian Cameron (Calogrenant), Sonya Saturday (The 2016 Republican Presidential Candidates), and Ajuan Mance (1001 Black Men). Many of the panelists contributed to the 2018 “All-Trans Comics Anthology” published by Stacked Deck Press entitled We’re Still Here. Avery allowed each of the panelists to highlight the meaning behind their work and their journey as transgender artists amidst the nation’s current political climate.

Ajuan Mance, who is also a professor of English at Mills College in Oakland, Calif., spoke about their well known illustration series 1001 Black Men, and the phenomenon of Black masculinity. Relating it to their experience as a trans person, Mance explained, “I wanted to explore the diversity of Black men’s experiences. I wanted to explore Black masculinity in all of its forms. I didn’t feel like the full diversity of what that means was represented in the wider forms of media. So I spent six and half years doing portraits of self-identifying Black men that I encountered,” Mance explained. Pointing out the impact of the series, Mance said, “Depicting Black maleness in all of its diversity really had opened up the possibilities, and gave me a chance to bridge the many different ways that particular intersection of identity is among those that identify as [Black men].”

Panelist Sonya Saturday, a Los Angeles-based cartoonist who often explores sexuality, queer identity, gender dynamics and American society in her work, spoke about the therapeutic nature of telling her story, along with her ability to give commentary on the country’s political state and President Donald Trump. “I’ve had several different bodies in my life…. I had to wear a ‘costume’ my whole life. I didn’t know consciously I was trans until three years ago,” Saturday explained. Describing how one of her stories addresses her realization of being trans, Saturday said, “In one scene I literally rip off my skin, and pull apart my [outer] body [of a male], to reveal a naked woman underneath. It was on the nose, but it was something I needed to convey. I was made to believe that [male] costume was real, and I had to finally tear it off. It’s been a hard process in finding my happiness, but it’s been worth it.” Saturday also created a popular political coloring book The 2016 Republican Presidential Candidates. The penetrating satire features Donald Trump on the cover. Saturday observed that the book was released in December of 2015, several months before Trump became the Republican nominee. She chose to put Trump on the cover because “he was the worst.”

The panel weighed in on the question if there is a need for transgender stories to become more mainstream within the media, and if it would be a hindrance or help in giving true representation to transgender people. Mance said, “The independent market has opened up so many possibilities for stories to be told, that may never make their way to the mainstream producers. But when someone from a marginalized community does get their story produced by the mainstream, for anyone who picks up that work it may be the most intimate conversation they’ve ever had with that marginalized demographic. So that’s one reason why trans stories picked up by mainstream press would be really important.” Tara Madison Avery added that many trans stories focus on the transition phase, but what is often uncharted is what goes on beyond that.

Speaking directly to People’s World on the need for transgender representation and hope for the future, Ajuan Mance said, “[We need] more stories of transgender people of color for sure. We need trans stories that are not tragic stories. I’d also like to see trans actors of all ethnicities playing cisgender roles. Also, transgender people of color need to be front and center telling our own stories.” Speaking to the recent controversy of Hollywood cisgender actress Scarlett Johansson signing on to play a transgender character, Mance noted, “The problem with the Scarlett Johansson issue is that trans women are not invited to play ciswomen roles, or roles that don’t specify. That leaves so little left for trans actors, so give a trans woman or trans guy a chance to play a trans character.”

When asked by a convention attendee how those who are not transgender can be better allies to the transgender community, Avery noted, “Support our work, buy our work. Earning a living as a creative can be hard, and it can be even harder for transgender artists pushing to get their stories told.”

Below is a list of works, and where you can purchase them, by transgender artists and writers from the panel:

We’re Still Here: An All Trans Comics Anthology

Qat Person by Dylan Edwards

Gumballs by Erin Nations

TransCat by Knave Murdok

The 2016 Republican Presidential Candidates by Sonya Saturday

1001 Black Men by Ajuan Mance

Calogrenant by Gillian Cameron

Trump’s Supreme Pick Escalates America’s War on Sex - by David Rosen

Trump’s Supreme Pick Escalates America’s War on Sex - by David Rosen

President Trump’s nomination of Judge Brett Kavanaugh to replace Justice Anthony Kennedy on the Supreme Court does not bode well for the future of sexual life in America. It has been widely reported that Kavanaugh, as a federal judge, sought to prevent a 17-year-old unauthorized immigrant from receiving an abortion, but was overruled by other jurists on the D.C. Court of Appeals.

Much of the current debate about Kavanaugh – and the previous appointee, Neil Gorsuch – focuses on the Court’s likely reversal (if not significant weakening) of the landmark 1973 decision, Roe v. Wade. The decision granted each woman the right to personal privacy, to decide the outcome of her pregnancy.

Over the last-half century, many of the Court’s most consequential decisions have involved the sex life of Americans. Abortion is but one. Gay rights and marriage, youth sex education and contraceptive use, and rights of transgender people are three others. Still others involve prostitution and sex trafficking, public media obscenity and zoning restrictions of commercial sex businesses (e.g., sex-toy outlets, “gentlemen’s” clubs). And then there’s the Internet, facilitating any and every conceivable sexual indulgence. Cumulatively, these decisions have helped profoundly transform the nation’s sexual culture.

Personal privacy is at the heart of the debate over Roe as well as many of the other sex-related Court decisions over the last-half century. Before Roe, each state had the authority to determine the limits of a woman’s privacy, especially in terms of her pregnancy … and, possibly, an abortion.

With Roe, the Court shifted the right of privacy from the individual state to the individual pregnant woman and extended the woman’s rights to the nation as a whole. It dramatically revealed how, up to then, American women — as “citizens” – had no personal right to sexual privacy. Roe grants each woman the right, the power, to decide the outcome of her pregnancy.

Moralist believe that a fetus, the unborn and as tiny as six weeks of gestation, should have ultimate power to determine the fate of the pregnancy and that of the birth mother. In many states, people can buy an automatic weapon but not a dildo. The boundaries of personal privacy will likely be a key concern of the “new” Court.

Fear of sex

In 1873, the U.S. Congress enacted the most draconian laws involving sexuality in the nation’s history, popularly known as the “Comstock laws.” Formally entitled “Suppression of Trade in, and Circulation of, Obscene Literature and Articles of Immoral Use,” they were named after Anthony Comstock. He was the nation’s leading moralist who spoke for a new generation of American Puritans. They fought against prostitution, obscene literature, birth control, race mixing, homosexuality and alcohol consumption. The Comstock laws led to the enactment of, in 1910, the Mann Act barring interstate sexual commerce (i.e., “white slavery”); in May, Pres. Trump pardon the boxing champion Jack Johnson who was convicted – and eventually imprisoned – for driving across a state line with his white wife. In 1919, the religious right’s efforts led to the adoption of the 18thAmendment establishing Prohibition and, in 1920, the adoption of 19thAmendment granting women the right to vote.

Often forgotten, in 1927, the Supreme Court decided that state-sanctioned sterilization was legal. Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes, the legendary voice of moral American, argued: “It is better for all the world, if instead of waiting to execute degenerate offspring for crime or to let them starve for their Imbecility, society can prevent those who are manifestly unfit from continuing their kind… Three generations of imbeciles are enough.” The decision led to the sterilization of some 60,000 citizens throughout the country. Obviously, the definitions of “imbecile” and “feeble-minded” were essentially arbitrary, morally and politically motivated, thus legally meaningless.

Birth control

In 1930, Margaret Sanger provoked one of the 20th century’s major legal confrontations over a woman’s right to birth control materials, this time as a free speech issue. She “illegally” imported Japanese condoms in violation of the Comstock laws. In 1936, the Supreme Court, in U.S. v One Package of Japanese Pessaries, struck down the prohibition because the material, as information and devices, served medical purposes, protecting the patient’s life. It was the first decision limiting the Comstock laws.

During the following two decades, and especially among WW-II servicemen stationed away-from-home or overseas, condoms became the principal means to prevent catching a sexually transmitted disease (STD). Griswold v. Connecticut (1965) overturned an old, Connecticut statute outlawing the use and distribution of contraceptives; the decisions granted physicians the right to provide counsel and contraceptives to a married couple. The Court ruled that the state could not limit the “zones of privacy,” including the “‘privacy in one’s associations,’” the privacy of the home and a general privacy that protected the institution of marriage.

In 1972, in Eisenstadt v . Baird , the Court extended Griswold, establishing the right of unmarried people to acquire and use contraceptives.

In 1973, abortion was legalized when the then all-male Supreme Court voted 7-2, in Roe v Wade, to overturn a Texas law making it a crime to assist a woman to have an abortion. The Count found the law violated a woman’s due process rights. Richard Nixon was the president at the time of the Roedecision and supported abortion, but in limited cases: “There are times when an abortion is necessary. I know that. When you have a black and a white or a rape.”

In the 1992 case, Planned Parenthood v. Casey, the Court reaffirmed the legal framework laid out in Roe.

Interracial marriage

In June 1967, the Court overturned, in Loving v. Virginia , a state statute barring interracial marriage was a violation of the 14th Amendment. The decision was but one in a line of Supreme Court and district court decisions reconfiguring the cultural and moral landscape. The Court’s ruling enunciated in Loving were extended to gay marriage in Lawrence v. Texas.

Homosexuality & gay marriage

In 1996, the Court, in Romer v. Evans, struck down a Colorado state constitutional amendment that prevented cities and towns from adopting their own bans on discrimination against gays, lesbians or bisexuals. The Court found the state amendment violated the 14th Amendment’s Equal Protection Clause.

In 1986, the Court upheld a Georgia law, in Bowers v. Hardwick, that made sodomy a criminal offense. However, nearly two decades later, in Lawrence v. Texas (2003), a 6-3 majority-decision reversed Bowers,invalidating a Texas’s ban on oral and anal sex between two men or two women. Justice Kennedy wrote the decision that overrode Bowers.

However, in the recent Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission (2018) decision, the Court found in favor of a baker who had refused to make a cake for a gay couple’s wedding.

Obscenity & free speech

In the post WW-II era, Court decisions transformed the media landscape. The landmark 1948 Paramount decree formally broke up the Hollywood studios’ monopoly on movie distribution. In 1952, the screening of Roberto Rossellini’s film, The Miracle, was a major controversy; in Burstyn v. Wilson, the Court overturned the 1915 Mutual Film Corporation ruling and formally granted movies First Amendment protection. According to the legal scholar, Richard Randall, “The Miracle decision did not outlaw government censor boards per se, but it did provide a constitutional basis for challenging their rulings.”

In Roth v . U.S. (1957), the Court found that “sex and obscenity are not synonymous ….” It found that obscene works were not entitled to constitutional protection . The decision established the principles of (i) community standards and (ii) considering the work as a whole. It went further, noting that, “Se x , a great and mysterious motive force in human life , has indisputably been a subject of absorbing interest to mankind through the ages; it is one of the vital problems of human interest and public concern . ”

Also, in 1957, the Court, in Adams Theatre v. Keenan, ruled to uphold a 1953 New Jersey decision that applied a higher obscenity standard to live public performances then to books, magazines, photos and films. The Newark, NJ, ordinance targeted a burlesque house and prohibited “the performance of any dance, episode, or musical entertainment, the purpose of which is to direct the attention of the spectator to the breasts, buttocks, or genital organs of the performer.”

In 1962, the Court ruled, in Manual v. Day, that the Post Office could not refuse mail services for male physique magazines. In his ruling, Justice John Marshall Harlan distinguished between a “prurient” appeal and an obscene image and wrote that the images in MANual were not “patently offensive” based on community standards.

In Jacobellis v. Ohio (1964), the Court found Louis Malle’s provocative French film, Les Amants (The Lovers), shown at a Cleveland Heights, OH, movie theatre, not obscene. Justice Potter Stewart, trying to distinguish between “soft” and “hard” core pornography, famously exclaimed, “I know it when I see it.”

In 1972, the Court ruled, in Byrne v. Karalexis, that Vilgot Sjöman’s Swedish film, I Am Curious (Yellow), distributed by Grove Press, was obscene because it depicted male frontal nudity and could be prohibited from being publicly screened.

In Miller v . California (1973), the meaning of obscenity was further refined.

One traditional evaluation criterion — whether a work was “utterly without redeeming social importance” — was revised. The Court now set three determining factors for obscenity: (i) whether the average person , applying contemporary community standards, would find that the work — taken as a whole – appealed to the prurient interest; (ii) whether the work depicts or describes sexual practice in a patently offensive manner; and (iii) whether the work has serious literary , artistic , political or scientific value.

In 1978, the Court, in FCC v. Pacifica , found seven words – “ shit,” “piss,” “fuck,” “cunt,” “cocksucker,” “motherfucker,” and “tits” — as obscene, unsuitable for broadcast on the public radio and television airways. New York’s Pacifica station, WBAI, rebroadcast a live performance by comedian George Carlin using the words during the day time – i.e., when children could be listening – and thus did not have First Amendment protection.

Pornography

The Supreme Court has long adhered to a belief that there is a Constitution difference between art, “soft core,” which titillates, and obscenity, “hard core,” which excites. This difference between art and obscenity was ineloquently drawn by Justice Potter Stewart’s legendary obfuscation, “I know it when I see it.” Nevertheless, it is a difference with significant consequence.

First Amendment protections do not apply to obscene or pornographic works. In 1982, the Supreme Court ruled, in New York v. Ferber , that child pornography was an exception to First Amendment free-speech protection. It insisted, “a child has been physically or psychologically harmed in the production of the work.” In this way, it was similar to a handful of other forms of expression, including libel, profanity and sedition also excluded from First Amendment protection.

The last major battle fought over obscenity took place a decade ago. On February 1, 2004, Janet Jackson and Justin Timberlake took the stage at the Super Bowl XXXVIII halftime show at Houston’s Reliant Stadium and — for about 9/16thof a second — a CBS TV audienceof nearly 150 million viewerswas exposed to a “costume malfunction” revealing Jackson’s bare breast and nipple shield.

The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) received 540,000 complaints about the incident, many call-ins orchestrated by conservative morality groups. FCC Chairman Michael Powell called Jackson’s exposure, “a classless, crass, and deplorable stunt,” and promised a tough response. In March 2004, the FCC imposed a $550,000 fine against CBS for its display of a “ fleeting instance” of indecency in line with its 1972 “seven dirty words” standard. CBS appealed the decision and, in June 2012 and, following an earlier ruling by the U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals in Philadelphia a gainst the FCC, the Supreme Court refused to reinstate the fine.

Prostitution

It appears that the Court has never directly ruled on the constitutionality of “consensual” commercial sex, prostitution.

Most recently, the Erotic Service Provider Legal, Education & Research Project (“ESPLERP”), an organization of San Francisco sex workers, lost a case challenging the constitutionality of California Penal Code section 647(b) that criminalizes the commercial exchange of sexual activity. The Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit refused to hear its appeal; ESPLERP is considering appealing to the Supreme Court.

In 2013, the Court overturned a law requiring any organization accepting U.S. funds to combat HIV/AIDS and related diseases overseas must explicitly denounce prostitution as a condition of receiving funding. Chief Justice John Roberts stated that while government can restrict the ways that funds are spent, it cannot require organizations to “pledge allegiance to the government’s policy of eradicating prostitution.” Such a pledge would violate their First Amendment rights.

The current case against Backstage.com over alleged solicitation of sex-trafficked children, if it gets to the Court, could fix a moral line on what is socially acceptable, one mediated by the vast web media culture.

The classroom

In 1988, the Court reversed a lower court decision and found that the 1981 Adolescent Family Life Act (AFLA) was not unconstitutional. In 1993, an out-of-court settlement stipulated that AFLA programs could not include religious references, use churches as venues or be presented at parochial schools during school hours. Will the new Court strengthen abstinence-only sex ed programs? Will “underage” youths be able to acquire contraceptive products? Similarly, will the Court support efforts by states to prohibit or restrict the teaching of global warming?

In a 1952 Court decision, Wieman v . Updergraff , Justice Felix Frankfurter wrote that teachers were “the priests of our democracy” because their task is “to foster those habits of open-mindedness and critical inquiry which alone make for responsible citizens.” In a secular world, the classroom is one of the most scared venues of free expression. Few other social institutions encourage careful reading, rigorous discourse and having a defensible point-of-view. Unstated but implicit, the classroom is one of the few social institutions that encourages the explicit challenge to established authority, the student’s “right” to question the teacher.

Zoning

States and localities claim the authority to regulate “obscene” businesses because they have “secondary effects” on the community. Such venues include theatres showing “adult” movies, adult bookstores and sex-toy shops, strip clubs featuring nude dancing and/or selling alcohol. Governments claim that such businesses increase crime, decrease property values and have a negative impact on a neighborhood. Strict zoning ordinances of a “ sexually oriented business” ( SOB) have been used to either block such a business from opening or set limits (e.g., 500 or 1,000 feet) to where such a business can be located vis-a-vis a residential dwelling, church, park or school.

In 1976, the Court ruled, in Young v. American Mini Theatres , that a city could set zoning ordinance to regulated porn theatres and other sex-related businesses. In New York, then-mayor Rudi Giuliani pushed sweeping regulations restricting sex-oriented video stores, X-rated theaters and topless bars in Times Square. The old midtown Honky Tonk has been turned into a metro Disneyland.

In Renton v. Playtimes Theatre (1986), the Court permitted cities to use zoning ordinances to restrict porn exhibition to 1,000 feet from a residential zone, single- or multiple-family dwelling, church, park or school.

In 2007, the Court chose to sidestep the issue of adult “vice,” refusing to hear a case brought by Sherri Williams, owner of Pleasures, a Decatur, AL, adult sex-toy shop. Her case dated from a violation of a 1998 Alabama anti-obscenity law that bans the sale of sex toys in the state. The Court’s refusal to hear her case signaled its intent to allow individual states to set their own “moral” standards. As Williams noted, “Alabama is the only state in the nation that still refuses to get with the times and overturn their silly ban on the sale of toys.

In March 2018, the Court refused to review of a lawsuit over a Sandy Springs, GA, ban on “gentlemen’s” clubs. The case began in 2006, when three “adult entertainment businesses” and an adult bookstore selling sex toys challenged newly implemented city codes banning the sale of alcohol in strip clubs, also placing zoning restrictions on where such businesses could operate. The businesses sued, claiming the city violated the First and Fourteenth Amendments; the city eventually revised its ordinance with regard to the bookstore.

***

In the first-quarter of the 21st century, many Americans assume a personal “right” to sexual privacy. Consensual, adult sexual fulfillment (however defined) is an expected – and accepted — aspect of a person’s life. Sex has been integrated into the mainstream of the marketplace, estimated to be a $70-billion enterprise. The Trump administration can be expected to undertake efforts to contain, if not suppress, popular sexual culture. Whether it succeeds will be determined to what extent the “new” Supreme Court — and Americans at large — accepts the personal right to sexual privacy, whether involving pleasure or an abortion.

https://web.archive.org/web/20180722141511/https://www.counterpunch.org/2018/07/20/trumps-supreme-pick-escalates-americas-war-on-sex/

Saturday, July 21, 2018

Florida Parking Argument Leads to Knock Down and Stand Your Ground Shooting Death - 19 July 2018

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9nFtxkJ7ywg - The video of the shooting death on Youtube





Tampa, Florida: On Tursday afternoon, 19 July 2018, a 47 year old man was arguing with a woman sitting in a car on a convenience store parking lot in Pinellas county outside of Tampa about being in a handicap parking space when her 28 year old boyfriend came out of the convenience store and simply walked up to the man and hit him in the chest with both hands knocking the man forcefully to the ground. Michael Drejka, 47, was attacked by Markeis McGlockton, who was 28. The older man on the parking lot tarmac then pulled out a pistol and shot the man who had knocked him down directly in the chest. The younger man then held his chest and turned and ran back into the convenience store.



There was no violence before Markeis McGlockton came out of the store. He thought he could simply walk up to this man and knock him down. But Michael Drejka had a weapon and used the gun to protect himself from further attack. Florida has a decade old 'stand your ground' law that gives people who are lawfully about their business to resist criminal attacks without simply retreating and calling for help. The police and district attorney have no plans to charge the shooter who defended himself in the parking lot from an unprovoked physical attack.



CCTV footage of the incident shows Drejka confronting the victim’s girlfriend about their car being parked in a handicapped parking spot without a permit. Witnessing the argument, McGlockton rushed to the scene and pushed Drejka to the ground. Drejka then pulled out his handgun and shot his assailant, who then wheeled away, clutching his chest.





Two of McGlockton’s children, a four-month-old and a three-year-old, were in the car at the time of the shooting. His five-year-old was in the store, according to the Tampa Bay Times.

https://www.tampabay.com/news/publicsafety/crime/No-arrest-in-fatal-shooting-during-argument-over-handicap-parking-space_170174041

Girlfriend Of 'Stand Your Ground' Shooting Victim Says Gunman 'Was Picking A Fight'

Hayley Miller ,HuffPost•July 23, 2018

The girlfriend of a Florida man who was shot dead during an altercation over a parking space last week says the gunman “wanted someone to be angry at.”

Britany Jacobs witnessed Michael Drejka, 47, gun down her boyfriend Markeis McGlockton, a 28-year-old father of three, in a convenience store parking lot in Clearwater on Thursday. Police, citing Florida’s “stand your ground” gun law that allows gun owners to use deadly force if they feel threatened, filed no charges.



Jacobs described the shooting and demanded justice in an interview Monday with ABC’s “Good Morning America.”

“He was a good man,” Jacobs said of McGlockton. “All he was trying to do was just protect his family.”

The confrontation began when McGlockton left his car idling in a handicap space Thursday to run into the store to purchase snacks. Jacobs was waiting in the car with their two children when Drejka approached and began “harassing” her for parking in a handicap space without a permit, she said.

“He wanted somebody to be angry at,” Jacobs said. “He just wanted someone to fight him. He was picking a fight. I’m just sitting, waiting for my family to come back to the car.”

McGlockton, seeing the confrontation, shoved Drejka to the ground, according to Jacobs. That’s when Drejka, who is white, pulled a gun and shot McGlockton, who is black, in the chest, just a few feet from the car, Jacobs said.

“The guy is on the ground and he pulls the gun out,” Jacobs told ABC. “My dude steps back ’cause my dude is fearing for his life ― all of us were.”

McGlockton, wounded, stumbled into the store, where he collapsed. He was pronounced dead roughly 30 minutes later at a hospital.

Drejka told police he feared for his life, Pinellas County Sheriff Bob Gualtieri said Friday at a press conference, where surveillance video of the shooting was released.

Police, citing the “stand your ground” law, did not arrest Drejka. (More famously, George Zimmerman was acquitted for the shooting of unarmed 17-year-old Trayvon Martin in a trial that provoked intense scrutiny of the law. While Zimmerman did not invoke “stand your ground” in his defense, the judge instructed the jury on the law, and it was cited by a juror after the trial as a factor in their deliberations.)

The sheriff’s office referred Drejka’s case to the state attorney’s office to determine whether he should be charged.

ABC reported that the owner of the convenience store, who was not named, has previously called the police to report Drejka for confronting customers over parking.

“I just want justice,” Jacobs told ABC. “I need something to be done because this is not right.”

Clarification: Language in this story has been amended to clarify the way Florida’s “stand your ground” law factored into Zimmerman’s acquittal.

This article originally appeared on HuffPost.

https://www.yahoo.com/news/girlfriend-apos-stand-ground-apos-142403830.html